How we rank gyms in our Best lists

Every Best list on Gym Montreal ranks gyms the same way: a Google rating weighted by its number of reviews, a mix of training types, and one gym per chain.

This page explains the method once, where the facts come from, and how votes and comments work.

How each gym is scored

  • We start from every gym listed in the neighbourhood on Gym Montreal.
  • We keep the gyms with at least 10 Google reviews.
  • Each gym gets a score: its Google rating times the logarithm of its review count.

A 4.9 from a dozen reviews does not automatically beat a 4.7 from several hundred.

A mix of training types

  • A second gym of the same type needs a clearly higher score to rank above a gym of another type.
  • Only one gym per chain is kept.

A list of ten gyms then covers more ways to train than ten similar gyms would.

Where the facts come from

  • Ratings, review counts, types and amenities: each gym's Google profile, as listed on Gym Montreal in November 2026.
  • What reviewers praise or criticize: what comes back in the Google reviews we collected.
  • A point raised only once is worded with caution.
  • Photos: the gyms' own websites. A gym without a usable photo shows a placeholder.
  • Map: OpenStreetMap contributors, through Protomaps.

Prices are not part of the method: call the gyms to compare.

Each list shows the date of its last update.

How votes and comments work

  • Under each gym, Agree and Disagree count one vote per person, per gym and per list.
  • To count each person once, we keep a hash of the IP address made with a secret key.
  • We never keep the IP address itself, only that hash and a random browser identifier.
  • Every vote and comment passes a Cloudflare Turnstile check against bots, and the number of votes and comments per hour is limited.
  • Comments are read by our team before they are published.

Votes and comments do not move a gym up or down by themselves.

We read them when we update a list.

No paid placement

  • No gym pays to appear in a Best list or for its place in it.
  • The featured place on a neighbourhood page is a separate paid option and never enters the rankings.

Corrections

A fact is wrong or out of date?

Tell us through the contact page and we will check it.

Gyms can also join the regroupement to correct and complete their listing.